French broadcaster fined after presenter failed to challenge hate speech

Another example of the measures taken by the French regulatory authority against a broadcaster for failing to challenge hate speech expressed by a presenter occurred on 28 September 2023 on CNews, during a discussion about antisemitism. A commentator claimed that antisemitism stemmed from Arab-Muslim immigration and associated the same group with drug trafficking.

How did the presenter respond? He did not challenge the statement. At the end, he merely remarked: “That is all we can say on this subject”.

The French media regulator fined the broadcaster €50,000. The presenter’s handling of the statement was also a factor in the decision.

CNews appealed the fine in court. On 6 November 2025, France’s highest administrative court, the Council of State, upheld the penalty. The court found that the sanction was proportionate and did not violate Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which protects freedom of expression.

I am bringing these cases to public attention because I believe it’s important to examine how democracies that we regard highly for their commitment to media freedom approach this debate.

These examples help us understand how such countries protect open debate and harsh criticism, while also assessing a broadcaster’s responsibility when statements made in a television studio encourage discrimination, hatred or violence.

Previous Presenter failed to clearly challenge guests’ statements, UK regulator Ofcom fines broadcaster £30,000

Follow us on social media:

Adress

Street “Papa Gjon Pali II”, Nr. 15, KP 1010, Tiranë

Copyright 2025 | Autoriteti Mediave Audiovizive | All Rights Reserved